Posted by: Nijay Gupta | February 19, 2008

Advice on Choosing a Research Topic for Doctoral Work in New Testament

When I was applying for PhD programs, I felt that I had a decent overall preparation for further studies…except my research proposal.  I felt like I could tick the boxes under language study, exegetical method, and breadth of knowledge.  When it came to formulating a good creative project I was quite weak.  I suspect that behind my rejection letter from Oxford was the question: dare you waste our time with this proposal?! Well, Durham took a chance on me and I hope I have made them proud thus far.  In any case, I have come a long way in two years and I feel very contented with my research and where it is going.  In any case, for those of you who are in the shoes I stood in a couple of years ago (or just thinking ahead), here is some advice.

1. Begin as early as you can to narrow your interest to a book of the NT or at least a small set of books (such as the Petrine letters, or Luke-Acts).  Over-specialization can make one overly myopic, but to be able to go deep in a vast field like NT studies means one has to narrow the scope.  Right now there is a renewed interest in the non-Pauline epistles such as Hebrews, James, and 1-2 Peter.  These are great areas to do research right now.  The field is pretty open.

2. The Magic is in the Method: You probably don’t want to do another thesis on righteousness in Romans.  Its been done.  Every 5th year for the last three three centuries.  It seems that the advances in research are often propelled by the application of approaches from different disciplines such as rhetorical theories, social-sciences, anthropology, etc… Where to begin in exploring such new approaches?  Try, The Open Text: New Directions in Biblical Studies? (ed. F. Watson) with engagements in reader criticism, feminist approaches, sociology, and more.

3. Read Published theses: Not just reviews of them or the introduction.  Take a good JSNTS monograph and read it cover to cover (or WUNT or SNTSMS).   Where to begin?  Try Dan Gurtner’s The Torn Veil (Book of Matthew) or Jerry Sumney’s Servants of Satan (opponents in Paul’s Letters).

4. Go to SBL and sit in on 3-4 groups of sessions of your first topic of interest (such as Gospel of John, or, rhetorical criticism in the NT) and then sit in on 1-3 groups of sessions of topics that just sound interesting but you know relatively little about (like, what the heck is Bhaktian? Oh, sounds interesting; or, semiotics - I’ve heard of it…can I use it in a sentence???).  If you can’t go, read the abstracts on the webpage of a wide range of papers.  You can learn a lot about a subject from abstracts - even if the paper ends up being unnecessarily convoluted.  In fact, many papers fail to live up to the expectation of the abstract.  Sad reality.

5. Read the journal  Currents in Biblical Research (SAGE).

6. Read footnotes in books and articles - there are a lot of good ideas left unexplored in footnotes.

7. Pay careful attention to the final section of a published thesis that should include: ‘areas for further exploration’ - where the conversation should continue to go.  You may find interesting ideas there.

8. Be a critical reader - don’t just read biblical scholarship passively, but engage in what is being said and ask, ‘what are the assumptions in the statements made here?’  ‘From where do these assumptions arise?’  ‘Is there another angle from which one can view the problem at hand?’  For many who were (and are) like me, its not just about sitting and thinking and coming up with a really good idea.  It is simply this: the more you read in the field, the more context you have for the state of academic discussion.  This is necessary preparation.

One quick caution - it is so easy to narrow your interests too far.  Some of the most useful insights into my research have come from reading books outside of my narrow research topic.  I do book reviews to force me to read more widely, so in addition to reading about Pauline theology and his use of metaphors (my main subject area), I also read a lot in the New Testament use of the Old Testament more generally, and I have an interest in 1 Peter.  Also, I like to read introductory books on Paul, and on the NT to keep me reflecting on the ‘basic’ questions.  Where do I find time?  When my wife is getting ready for bed.  When the toddler is napping.  Sometimes if I am eating alone.  You can find time if it is important to you.

Best wishes for those who are wanting to embark on the adventure of NT research - it is a very rewarding experience and a lot of fun.

Responses

Good suggestions.

Thanks,
Lou

You forgot the other important factor…dumb luck, or is it divine illumination. Either way, people just sometimes seem stumble on ideas. But people that find them are most often those who have put them in a place to find them, that is, those who have followed the excellent ideas above.

A lot of the fruitful projects these days comes out of finding two areas that address similar issues but don’t talk to each other effectively.

One other idea, just ask lecturers and professors you trust about areas they think would be interesting.

Ben,
Thanks for this. Yes, many if not most people just bump into something interesting. But, this, in a sense, is my point behind intentionally reading lots of monographs because the more you read, the more opportunities you have to ’stumble’ into something. The point, I guess, is that many people like me are prone to stress out about having a great original idea that will wow potential supervisors. I wasted hours looking for that idea, when I should have spent that time getting to know a field well enough to see its weaknesses and breaking points. To be a good researcher, you must be a good critical reader. But, yes, luck also has its place. But, for those who stress out like me, well, we take no comfort in hoping for our luck to change… :)

I think it is also important to know what your adviser’s interest’s are. You should read everything he or she has written and, as you mentioned, pay special attention to the footnotes and suggestions of needs for future research. I think it will go more smoothly if your research in some way advances your doktorvater’s (oder -mutter’s) career and makes your professor and the institution proud.

Yes, Mark. Thank you. I would note that some have been successful in arguing directly against their supervisor (in a respectful way, of course). SPecifically I have Simon Gathercole in mind who took Jimmy Dunn on on boasting in 2nd Temple Judaism and launched an attack against the New Perspective (especially as Dunn conceives of it). But, he still made his institution (Durham) proud and he comes back on occasion to read a paper at the seminar here (and now he’s at Cambridge, so he is doing something right!).

Great thoughts, Nijay. I will be beginning a doctoral program in the fall, so these are all important things for me to keep in mind. My research will be slightly different depending on where I go, though, so I’m waiting to find out which advisor I’ll be working under and thus what I should focus more of my attention on as I prepare.

Thank you for writing down these useful information. I have found a research topic, but don’t know how to write an impressive proposal, what will be your suggestions?

Thanks for taking the time to work this blog in the way you have - it gives us all something to think about. I admit I would like to do doctoral work - I still need to answer the question “why?” Then I would need to figure out “what?” Right now my interests are in just about anything having to do with Jesus (I know that is an over represented field) and I like your suggestion on the non-pauline letters particularly Hebrews because, again, it’s focus is Jesus, and I could get into the OT as well, since it is a Hebrew exegesis of the OT in a lot of ways.

Also, right now, I am pastoring, so I would want something that can keep me in ministry as well. Regent is one possibility I am considering.

They say there are three things one needs to pursue doctoral work: brains, money, and guts! Some have the guts, do others? Do I?

Brian,
If you are interested in studying Hebrews, you might consider Emory University (Luke T Johnson) or University of Gloucestershire (Andrew Lincoln). Also, if you are thinking about American Seminaries, I think the best one right now is Fuller (and maybe you might want to work with MM Thompson). There’s always Durham - we have a very warm and friendly environment and many professors here are in ministry. For Gospels, we have two of the best - Stephen Barton and William Telford. Stephen would be really great for John’s Gospel.

Best wishes
Nijay

[...] along was mentioned by Stephen Carlson at Hypostyposeis concerning Nijay Gupta’s post “Advice on choosing a research topic for doctoral work in New [...]

This is a very healthy, all researchers need most of these ideas….
Students are often driven by emotions in selection of a research topic, these emotions are in most cases related to a students experience in life, fear of meeting dateline in submission of a research proposal, ease in gathering data or due to ugly of lovely experiences encountered. If these emotions are not handled diligently, the selected topic is likely to be challenging and one may end up not completing or being very much frustrated in his/her research.
If one is driven by emotions in selecting a research topic, the selected research topic may be difficult to complete, it may be rejected by the supervisor due to its inability to add value to knowledge or it may be very difficulty if not impossible to carry out investigations on the selected topic leave alone earning very little marks due to lack of objectivity in your research topic among other factors.–avoid emotions in selecting a research topic

This is a very healthy topic, all researchers need most of these ideas….
Students are often driven by emotions in selection of a research topic, these emotions are in most cases related to a students experience in life, fear of meeting dateline in submission of a research proposal, ease in gathering data or due to ugly or lovely experiences encountered. If these emotions are not handled diligently, the selected topic is likely to be challenging and one may end up not completing or being very much frustrated in his/her research.
If one is driven by emotions in selecting a research topic, the selected research topic may be difficult to complete, it may be rejected by the supervisor due to its inability to add value to knowledge or it may be very difficulty if not impossible to carry out investigations on the selected topic leave alone earning very little marks due to lack of objectivity in your research topic among other factors.–avoid emotions in selecting a research topic

Nijay (and Brian),
Thanks for the nod to Fuller Seminary, that’s where I’m finishing up my M.Div. right now. I’ve taken several doctoral seminars during my time at Fuller and have been very pleased. Don’t forget Joel Green who just came on board this past year and is already starting to assist doctoral students with their work. We also have a couple new NT scholars with great potential in Love Sechrest (recent grad of Duke under Marcus) and David Downs (recent grad of Princeton TS under Gaventa).

Приветствую всех!
У меня такой вопрос,кто что интересное подскажет буду признателен.
Мы с друзьями собираемся поехать в круиз по просторам России и ближнего зарубежья месяца на два на своих машинах,но не как не можем согласовать маршрут,если у кого уже был опыт такого путешествия,может,что посоветуете.Девчонок с собой не берем,думаем,что во все городах России с этим не будет проблем,если у кого будут рекомендации и в вопросе отдыха с девушками тоже буду признателен.

С уважением Сеньчик

Приветствую всех!
У меня такой вопрос,кто что интересное подскажет буду признателен.
Мы с друзьями собираемся поехать в круиз по просторам России и ближнего зарубежья месяца на два на своих машинах,но не как не можем согласовать маршрут,если у кого уже был опыт такого путешествия,может,что посоветуете.Девчонок с собой не берем,думаем,что во все городах России с этим не будет проблем,если у кого будут рекомендации и в вопросе отдыха с девушками тоже буду признателен.

С уважением Сеньчик

[...] good advice on choosing a research (dissertation) topic for doctoral work in New [...]

Leave a response

Your response:

Categories